When should I stay in an Airbnb versus hotel?

When planning a trip, nationally or internationally, I frequently get asked, “How do I know the best accommodation to book?” With so many options and platforms available today, knowing where to start looking can be overwhelming. I typically research hotels and Airbnbs in the desired area to decide. Several factors come into play in why I book a particular place. Some of the main questions I think about before booking are:

  1. How many people are going? Is this a small group, couple, or family reunion?
  2. Do I need to rent a car? Is everything near the accommodation, or is it more convenient to drive? Does the hotel/Airbnb offer free parking?
  3. Is there a significant price differential between the two?
  4. What is the vibe I am looking for? Are you seeking something more private? Is a resort the best option so you never have to leave?
  5. Did previous guests enjoy their stay at this particular hotel/Airbnb?
  6. Are extra amenities, like a concierge or spa, essential?
  7. Do you want to immerse yourself in the local culture (if international)?
  8. How long am I staying? Is it a quick overnight stay or a week-long vacation?
  9. What provides the best overall value?

Airbnb more often suits my needs for several reasons. My favorite things about staying at an Airbnb are:

  • Easy self-check-in processes
  • Abundance of choices depending on the location
  • Reading recent reviews
  • Filtering to Superhosts for a better guest experience
  • More spacious for larger groups
  • Airbnb experiences platform for good local activities
  • Extra amenities like kitchen, pool, gym, game rooms, etc., depending on the place booked
  • More "homey" feel
  • Ease of searching and filtering to your specific criteria
           

When I stay at hotels, there are services that usually only resorts or hotels can offer. My favorite things about staying in a hotel/resort are:

  • Amenities provided on-site (gym, pool, restaurants, bars, spa)
  • Concierge services
  • Pre-planned guest activities
  • Baggage drop-off service
  • Complimentary breakfast (depending on hotel/resort)
  • Airport transfers (depending on hotel/resort)
  • Social events with other guests
  • If traveling with a large group, you can have your separate rooms if you want privacy
  • More flexible check in and out times (depending on availability)

Recent posts

View all posts

Honeymoonin’ in the Maldives

December 3, 2023
5 minute read

Cancun Guide

October 17, 2023
3 min read

Maximize Vacation Days in 2025

November 14, 2023
1 minute